FYI, I did NOT get these in consideration of a review. I'm a normal consumer, just like you. The price was right, though and did influence my decision to buy. So here's my review...As you can see in the photo, I have fairly thick ankles. My feet tend to be a little wide in the front, are swollen some days, and I'm getting a bunion on one foot. I weigh around 200 lbs, which doesn't help (but am losing, YAY), and I haven't worn heels in two decades. I'm a mess, I know. Most shoes absolutely kill my feet and I have to be pretty picky. But after reading the reviews, I bit the bullet and got these booties in a half size larger (normally wear a 7.5). Generally, when I buy a half size larger, I regret it, because the heels slip too much. But, amazingly, these seem to fit really, really well.First, I can walk in them without falling over. I know that sounds funny, but I am a klutz and often twist ankles. The heel height is comfortable for me, though I probably couldn't go any higher. The foot bed is fairly hard/stiff, but I think a cushiony insole may solve that problem. I'm sure they will get more flexible after they're broken in. The arch doesn't hit me just right, but it's pretty darn close. The boots aren't causing any problem with my bunion, yet, but again, a cushion pad may help if I do have problems. I did not have any trouble getting them on, as some reviewers mentioned. I thought I would, so I'm happy about that. I do like the wider tops and am thrilled that the boots don't rub my ankles raw, especially when I flex my foot. They feel really soft inside the shaft. And finally, they are just really, really cute boots.Having said all that, I will update IF I experience any problems. Cross your fingers and TOES!